2025 Dynasty Rookie Mock Draft (Based on Chad Reuter’s NFL.com 2025 NFL MOCK DRAFT) Best of the rest

Kyle McCord | QB | New York Jets | 3.73
With Rodgers gone and Fields on a short-term trial, McCord has a real shot at carving out a future in New York. Fields got a “show me” deal, and if he stumbles, McCord could step in — not as a flier, but as the planned contingency. He’s got tools, pedigree, and draft capital that says the Jets see something. In Superflex formats, he’s a sneaky stash who could end up starting games sooner than expected.

Will Howard | QB | Pittsburgh Steelers | 4.123
Howard showed a solid floor on the big stage, and now lands with a stability-first franchise in Pittsburgh. The Steelers don’t panic — they build around their QBs, and if you can process the offense and manage the game, they’ll keep you in the saddle. Howard may never be a fantasy star, but he’s the kind of guy who could settle in as a steady QB2 with weekly floor value in Superflex leagues. Boring? Maybe. But boring that starts is still better than upside that never sees the field.

Dillon Gabriel (QB, Miami Dolphins – 4.135)
If you had to handpick a landing spot for Gabriel, Mike McDaniel’s quick-hitting, timing-based offense might be the perfect match. He’s not going to be a fantasy star, but if Tua misses time (which, let’s be honest, is always on the table), Gabriel could step in and keep the offense clicking. He’s accurate, he’s decisive, and he fits the rhythm. Gabriel truthers won’t let him fall out of the 3rd in Superflex — and frankly, they might be right.

Brashard Smith (WR, Minnesota Vikings – 5.139)
This is the kind of player who could easily sneak into the 3rd round of rookie drafts — and maybe should. Smith has a fantasy-friendly skill set, with burst, versatility, and just enough “what if” to get dynasty managers intrigued. In Minnesota, he joins a depth chart with an aging Aaron Jones and a limited Jordan Mason, which opens the door for him to carve out a role quickly. With the right usage, he could go from Day 3 afterthought to sneaky PPR flex before long.

Ollie Gordon (RB, Miami Dolphins – 5.155)
Gordon’s star burned fast and bright, then fizzled just as quickly. But Miami? Miami might be the spark to light it up again. He’s got the build and style to step into that Mostert role, the one Wright couldn’t quite grasp in 2024, and that’s a direct ticket to fantasy relevance. Just a year removed from winning the Doak Walker Award, Gordon lands in an offense that could resurrect his stock overnight. Don’t be shocked if he’s right back on highlight reels before long.

Donovan Edwards (RB, Baltimore Ravens – 6.212)
Once the face of the NCAA 25 revival and a national champ with Michigan, Edwards looked like a future star. But those may end up being the highlight reel of his career. He slips to the 6th round, landing in Baltimore — an offense that historically hasn’t featured RBs in the passing game, which is his best trait. Still, maybe this signals a shift. Maybe the Ravens are ready to expand their offense and tap into what made Edwards special at Michigan. Or maybe this is just a name we remember fondly from what almost was.

LeQuint Allen (RB, Washington Commanders – 7.245)
Allen is a project player, but one who’s improved every year and brings a rare receiver-level route tree to the RB position. He’s got the hands, the agility, and the upside... but unfortunately, not the draft capital. Sliding to the 7th round will temper even the most bullish believers, and that draft day fall will push him down rookie boards. Still, if Washington gets creative — or injuries open the door — Allen could be a PPR dark horse worth stashing in deeper formats.

Tory Horton (WR, Los Angeles Chargers – 6.199)
If Horton had about 10–15 more pounds on him, we’re probably talking about a Day 2 pick. He’s a polished route runner with dependable hands. The Chargers give him everything he needs to succeed: a franchise QB in Herbert, a coaching staff that values player development, and a depth chart that’s rebuilding from scratch. He’s not flashy, but Horton has the talent and the setup to grow into an NFL contributor — and maybe a fantasy flex if things break right.

Xavier Restrepo (WR, Tennessee Titans – 6.178)
Restrepo’s 40 time was painfully pedestrian, and the fact that it’s been mildly disputed doesn’t exactly help his case. The result? A 6th-round slide that makes him a long shot in the eyes of most dynasty players. But hey — it’s the Titans. The depth chart is paper-thin after Ridley. If the dust settles and Restrepo’s still standing, he could be a sneaky slot option, and a decent late dart throw in deep leagues. Low expectations, but low risk too.

Harold Fannin Jr. (TE, New York Jets – 4.111)
Fannin is going to climb rookie drafts thanks to his absurd college production profile and a fanbase that’s already pounding the table. Landing in New York gives him a real shot to start early, but let’s be honest — this isn’t exactly a fantasy-friendly offense. Still, Fannin is a legit weapon if he can earn trust and stay on the field. The talent is there to become a TE2 with upside, and if the Jets offense ever finds a pulse, he could turn into a steal at this ADP.

Oronde Gadsden II (WR/TE, Philadelphia Eagles – 5.164)
This is the kind of raw talent I’m happy to bet on at this point in the draft. Gadsden has the athleticism to be a mismatch nightmare, but he’s got work to do on technique and polish. Luckily, he lands in Philly — one of the best organizations in the league when it comes to developing versatile weapons. If anyone can mold him into a fantasy asset, it’s the Eagles. It might take time, but if he clicks, you’re looking at a potential move-TE or hybrid monster who can exploit defenses every week.

Gunnar Helm (TE, Miami Dolphins – 4.117)
Helm isn’t going to light up your group chat, but landing in Miami makes him quietly interesting. He’s a solid blocker with just enough athleticism to leak out for sneaky production in a Mike McDaniel offense that thrives on unpredictability. You’re not drafting him expecting fireworks, but if he earns the trust to stay on the field, he could become one of those annoying bye-week fillers who sneaks a TD here and there. In tight end premium formats, that’s worth a stash.