Vet Fatigue Report - 06.10.25
We’re shifting gears from 2nd-year running backs to vintage wide receivers. These are three names who’ve been staples in the fantasy community for years and are now inching toward the twilight of their careers. Two are changing teams for the first time, while the third enters a second year with his. All three have been cornerstone pieces on championship rosters. Yes, they’re obvious sell candidates now, but what value is out there? And if you’re chasing a title, are any of them worth acquiring as a short-term flex?
All data and trades were pulled on 6.08.25 from Dynasty Daddy and KTC.
Calvin Ridley | WR | Tennessee Titans
KTC: WR56 | Dynasty Nerds: WR57 | Dynasty Daddy: WR56 | Sleeper: WR48
Current ADP Range: ~110–120 overall (Round 9)
Trend: Up from ~130 overall (Round 11) over the past month; holding in the WR4 range
Ridley has seen a slight bump in ADP over the last month, riding the wave of optimism surrounding rookie QB Cam Ward. He managed a top-30 fantasy finish last year with Will Levis scattershot passing, now he’s paired with the number one overall pick. Expected to lead the Titans in targets, that’s a solid weekly floor.
At 30, Ridley hasn’t missed a game in the last 2 seasons since returning from his “sabbatical” and doesn’t appear to be fading. If anything, he may thrive off of Ward’s creative play style and charisma. A WR2 season is likely, especially if Ward hits early.
And yet… he’s being drafted after Cooper Kupp in some leagues despite being younger, healthier, and projected to be the WR1 in a wide-open offense. That makes Ridley a sneaky value if the price stays in the 10th-round range.
The question is, how much is the market catching on? Are we talking flex pricing, or higher?
Ridley Rising. This feels like instant production in the 9th–10th round of a startup.
Strong Playoff Piece
A mid to future 2nd for reliable WR2 production is easy money for a contender. He’s the clear WR1 tied to the No. 1 overall pick, wheels up!
Right Player, Wrong Price?
Some managers are spending 2027 1sts, and that’s a strong vote of confidence. But there are better ways to use that capital.
Smart Package.
Pairing Ridley with a boom-bust like Shaheed to land McLaurin is a sharp move. You gain a year and real ceiling. Shaheed’s value likely fades with Shough under center.
Stop Donating Value
Deals like McMillan for Ridley and Sinnott are straight-up losses, especially in TEP. Even Bech for Ridley feels light if you’re making a push. Contenders should be acquiring Ridley, not giving him away.
Pick Your Flavor
If you see these players as equal, take the free 3rd and walk away happy. But if you believe in Ridley, a 3rd isn't enough to cash out.
WR Need vs. SF Logic
This is a preference play, but in SuperFlex, it’s tough to pass on the QBs. Unless these are your QB4 and QB5, Ridley doesn’t swing the value. Know your build, and don’t sacrifice value for depth.
Verdict: Sell. Ridley will be a solid fantasy contributor for the next two seasons, unless Cam completely flops. If you want to use his points on the road to a championship, I completely endorse it. But now is the time to get out before his market collapses. His age and QB situation are huge risks. While his break may grant him a couple extra years of production, I don’t see his market value returning to this level again.
Cooper Kupp | WR | Seattle Seahawks
KTC: WR60 | Dynasty Nerds: WR51 | Dynasty Daddy: WR60 | Sleeper: WR51
Current ADP Range: ~135 overall (Round 11)
Trend: Down from 85 overall (Round 7) in early 2024; steady WR5 range
It feels like just yesterday Cooper Kupp was winning the triple crown and a trip to Disney World. He came out firing in 2022, looking ready to repeat another monster fantasy season. But a badly sprained ankle in Week 10 required a tightrope procedure and ended his year. Since then, he’s missed nine more games across two seasons with recurring hamstring and ankle issues.
Now at age 31, Kupp moves on from Matthew Stafford in Los Angeles to Sam Darnold in Seattle. The Seahawks are expected to lean into the run with Klint Kubiak, and target volume won't get heavier with Jaxon Smith-Njigba emerging. Kupp’s man route win/target rates and elite YAC ability have dipped as age and injuries mount.
Does he have another fantasy-relevant season in him, or should you move him for whatever's left in the tank? Let’s check the market and see where dynasty managers stand.
These Expert Consensus Rankings have Cooper Kupp ranked as the WR46.
However, current startup ADP is around the 11th round.
I don’t feel comfortable with him over the players he is being drafted around, including Diggs.
Wash Your Hands or Hold to the Grave
I’m surprised how many managers are shipping off future 2nds for Kupp. I’m not that brave. Sure, there’s a narrow path to WR2 production… but you’re squinting hard to see it. If that offer hits your inbox, take the pick or prepare to ride him into retirement.
Kupp Market Is on Fire — and You Should Be Selling
I spoke too soon. Not only are 2nds being tossed around for Kupp, some managers are moving 1st-round rookies to get him. These feel like heists for the value being sent back. The market is hotter than expected.
Stack the Leverage
I could take either side of this deal depending on team structure and strategy. If you’re targeting a veteran, this is how you do it — the 2027 1st for DJ Moore could’ve stood alone, but asking for Kupp back gives you a bonus piece that may hold more value to a contender down the road.
I’d use Charbonnet to pivot off Kupp for a higher-upside asset like Terry McLaurin any day.
Tracy feels like a fair offer, but I’d still lean toward holding the younger RB, unless I’m desperate for WR depth.
These are the types of deals I expected to see more of: mid-level players or late picks, not high-end rookies being moved to acquire him
Landing Kupp just for moving back three spots in the 2nd round isn’t something you can count on — but rookie fever is real.
Verdict: Sell. There’s still a market. I was genuinely surprised by how much commitment the dynasty community has to his name. He’s in his 30s, changing teams, and won’t be the primary target anymore. With the type of player Kupp is, a final hurrah wouldn’t be shocking, but I’m not paying a premium to find out.
Deebo Samuel | WR | Washington Commanders
KTC: WR55 | Dynasty Nerds: WR47 | Dynasty Daddy: WR55 | Sleeper: WR45
Current ADP Range: ~120 overall (Round 9)
Trend: Down from 75 overall (Round 6) in 2024, slipping 3+ rounds; WR4 range
Name Value ≠ Real Value
I get that Reed feels risky and Shakir feels boring, but Deebo’s in that same tier. Don’t let the past cloud what he is today: a flex gamble with declining juice.
Deebo Samuel heads to Washington, pairing with rookie phenom Jayden Daniels as the Commanders add another dimension into their offense. While there’s excitement about his arrival and the ceiling in this creative system, Deebo is coming off a disappointing year, barely averaging 10 fantasy points per game.
2025 is a contract year, so motivation won’t be an issue. But the truth is, Deebo has only produced two truly great fantasy seasons in six years, both propped up by manufactured touches and rush attempts. His lack of elite route running limits his ability to thrive on scheme dependence.
Yes, the situation is fantastic, and Daniel’s dynamic playmaking could unlock explosive weeks. But expectations need to be tempered. You're betting on efficiency and gadget usage more than stable WR2 volume.
Is the market still buying into the ceiling, or has the floor finally caught up to his cost? Let’s see.
Pay for Proven Greatness
This is a cheap price for BTJ. Packaging Deebo with a rookie like Quinshon, T-Mac, or even Cam Ward is a smash accept for the BTJ side. You’re consolidating into a cornerstone.
Pick Your Prototype
This one comes down to preference, and I can see managers leaning either way. I’m still taking BTJ, but I understand betting on JSN with the added piece.
It’s a conviction move.
McLaurin Mania Is Real
Managers are packaging aging vets like Deebo and upside names like Pickens to chase Terry. It feels pricey when other managers acquired him for significantly less than that with Ridley or Kupp. Proving, each league is its a unique ecosystem of value.
Samuel’s Just Bubble Wrap Now
Deebo Samuel feels like a throw-in in these deals. Henry for a 1st is standard, but adding both Pickens and Samuel feels steep. Same with the CMC trade, CMC for a 1st is a solid exchange, but adding Deebo and the 2.10 either inflates the price or highlights how little the market values Samuel. It’s becoming clear: in many leagues, Deebo isn’t the prize — he’s the packaging.
Buy the Discount, Not the Dream
Deebo at a late 2nd or 3rd-round price is worth exploring, even a roster clogger and a 4th gets it done in some leagues. There are outcomes where he pops in Washington, but don’t burn real capital chasing them.
Cheap Shots with Premium Upside
Give me these TE darts in a TEP, or even a standard league. I love both landing spots, and if just one of them hits, you’ve got a future goldmine.
Verdict: Buy Cheap, or Sell Quick. The Samuel market is cooling, but savvy managers are still finding ways to use him as an upgrade piece. In the BTJ deals, he helped bridge the gap to elite assets. But in trades for Henry and CMC, he looks more like a throw-in. There are absolutely paths where Deebo provides value to your fantasy roster, but I’m not taking that risk unless the cost is dirt cheap.
